Are interventions with batterers effective? A meta-analytical review

  1. Ramón Arce 1
  2. Esther Arias 1
  3. Mercedes Novo 1
  4. Francisca Fariña 1
  1. 1 Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, Spain
Revista:
Psychosocial Intervention

ISSN: 1132-0559

Ano de publicación: 2020

Volume: 29

Número: 3

Páxinas: 153-164

Tipo: Artigo

DOI: 10.5093/PI2020A11 DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openAcceso aberto editor

Outras publicacións en: Psychosocial Intervention

Resumo

The inconsistency in the results both internally and between of previous meta-analyses on batterer intervention program efficacy, and the publication of new batterer interventions underscored the need for an up-to-date meta-analyticalreview. A total of 25 primary studies were found from literature search, obtaining 62 effect sizes, and a total sample of 20,860 intervened batterers. The results of a global meta-analysis showed a positive, significant, and of a mediummagnitude effect size for batterer interventions, but not generalizable. Nevertheless, the results exhibited a significantly higher rate of recidivism measured in couple reports (CRs) than in official records (ORs). As a consequence, intervention efficacy measuring in CRs was null, whilst in ORs was positive and significant. As for the intervention model, positive andsignificant effects were observed under the Duluth Model and cognitive-behavioural treatment programs (CBTPs), but a higher effect size was obtained with CBTPs in comparison to the Duluth Model (under this model, interventions may have negative effects, i.e., an increase in recidivism rate). In relation to intervention length, short interventions failed to reduce recidivism in ORs and may have negative effects, while long interventions were effective in reducing recidivism rate in ORs without negative effects. Efficacy evaluations in short follow-ups were invalid as artificially boosted recidivismreduction rate. Limitations of ORs and short follow-ups as measures of the intervention efficacy and implications of results for batterer intervention are discussed.

€ Ver financiamento

Información de financiamento

This research has been sponsored by a grant of the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness (PSI2017-87278-R).

Financiadores

Referencias bibliográficas

  • Amado, B. G,Arce, R,Herraiz, A.. (2015). Psychological injury in victims of child sexual abuse: A meta-analytic review. Psychosocial Intervention. 24. 49-62
  • Arce, R.. (2017). Análisis de contenido de las declaraciones de testigos: evaluación de la validez científica y judicial de la hipótesis y la prueba forense [Content analysis of the witness statements: Evaluation of the scientific and judicial validity of the hypothesis and the forensic proof]. Acción Psicológica. 14. 171
  • Arce, R,Fariña, F.. (2010). Diseño e implementación del programa Galicia de reeducación de maltratadores: una respuesta psicosocial a una necesidad social y penitenciaria [Design and implementation of the Galicia program for batterer re-education: A psychosocial answer to a social and penitentiary need]. Psychosocial Intervention. 19. 153
  • Arce, R,Fariña, F,Fraga, A. I.. (2000). Género y formación de juicios en un caso de violación [Gender and juror judgment making in a case of rape]. Psicothema. 12. 623
  • Arce, R,Fariña, F,Novo, M.. (2014). Competencia cognitiva en penados primarios y reincidentes: implicaciones para la reeducación [Cognitive competence among recidivist and non-recidivist prisoners: Implications for the rehabilitation]. Anales de Psicología. 30. 259
  • Arce, R,Fariña, F,Seijo, D,Novo, M.. (2015). Assessing impression management with the MMPI-2 in child custody litigation. Assessment. 22. 769
  • Arce, R,Fariña, F,Vilariño, M.. (2015). Daño psicológico en casos de víctimas de violencia de género: un estudio comparativo de las evaluaciones forenses [Psychological injury in intimate partner violence cases: A contrastive analysis of forensic measures]. Revista Iberoamericana de Psicología y Salud. 6. 72-80
  • Arias, E,Arce, R,Vilariño, M.. (2013). Batterer intervention programmes: A meta-analytic review of effectiveness. Psychosocial Intervention. 22. 153
  • Babcock, J. C,Green, C. E,Robie, C.. (2004). Does batterers’ treatment work? A meta-analytic review of domestic violence treatment. Clinical Psychology Review. 23. 1023
  • Babcock, J. C,Steiner, R.. (1999). The relationship between treatment, incarceration and recidivism of battering: A program evaluation of Seattle’s coordinated community response to domestic violence. Journal of Family Psychology. 13. 46-59
  • Bennett, L,Call, C,Flett, H,Stoops, C.. (2005). Program completion, behavioral change and re-arrest for the batterer intervention system of Cook County, Illinois. Illinois Criminal Justice Information Authority. Chicago, IL.
  • Bowen, E,Gilchrist, E. A,Beech, A. R.. (2005). An examination of the impact of community-based rehabilitation on the offending behaviour of male domestic violence offenders and the characteristics associated with recidivism. Legal and Criminological Psychology. 10. 189-209
  • Brame, R,Kaukinen, C,Gover, A. R,Lattimore, P. K.. (2015). No-contact orders, victim safety, and offender recidivism in cases of misdemeanor criminal domestic violence: A randomized experiment. American Journal of Criminal Justice. 40. 225
  • Coulter, M,VandeWeerd, C.. (2009). Reducing domestic violence and other criminal recidivism: Effectiveness of a multilevel batterers intervention program. Violence and Victims. 24. 139
  • Davis, R. C,Taylor, B. G,Maxwell, C. D.. (1998). Does batterer treatment reduce violence? A randomized experiment in Brooklyn. Justice Quarterly. 18. 171-201
  • Dobash, R,Dobash, R. E,Cavanagh, K,Lewis, R.. (1996). Reeducation programs for violent men: An evaluation.
  • Dunford, F. W.. (2000). The San Diego Navy experiment: An assessment of interventions for men who assault their wives. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 68. 468
  • (2014). European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. Violence against women: An EU-wide survey. Results at a glance.
  • Fariña, F,Redondo, L,Seijo, D,Novo, M,Arce, R.. (2017). A meta-analytic review of the MMPI validity scales and indexes to detect defensiveness in custody evaluations. International Journal of Clinical and Health Psychology. 17. 128
  • Feder, L. R,Dugan, L.. (2004). Testing a court-mandated treatment program for domestic violence offenders: The Broward experiment. National Institute of Justice. Washington, DC.
  • Feder, L,Wilson, D. B.. (2005). A meta-analytic review of court-mandated batterer intervention programs: Can courts affect abusers’ behavior?. Journal of Experimental Criminology. 1. 239
  • Gallego, R,Novo, M,Fariña, F,Arce, R.. (2019). Child-to-parent violence and parent-to-child-violence: A meta-analytic review. European Journal of Psychology Applied to legal Context.
  • Gondolf, E. W.. (2000). Reassault at 30-months after batterer program intake. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology. 44. 111
  • Graña, J. L,Redondo, N,Muñoz-Rivas, M. J,Cuenca, M. L.. (2017). Short-term treatment response, attrition and recidivism in a partner violent men typology compared with a control group. Psicología Conductual. 25. 465
  • Haggård, U,Freij, I,Danielsson, M,Wenander, D,Långström, N.. (2017). Effectiveness of the IDAP treatment program for male perpetrators of intimate partner violence: A controlled study of criminal recidivism. Journal of Interpersonal Violence. 32. 1027
  • Hasisi, B,Shoham, E,Weisburd, D,Haviv, N,Zelig, A.. (2016). The “care package” prison domestic violence programs and recidivism: A quasi-experimental study. Journal of Experimental Criminology. 12. 563
  • Hedges, L. V,Olkin, I.. (1985). Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Academic Press.
  • Herman, K,Rotunda, R,Williamson, G,Vodanovich, S.. (2014). Outcomes from a Duluth model batterer intervention program at completion and long term follow-up. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation. 53. 1-18
  • Holt, V. L,Kernic, M. A,Wolf, M. E,Rivara, F. P.. (2003). Do protection orders affect the likelihood of future partner violence and injury?. American Journal of Preventive Medicine. 24. 16-21
  • Jenkins, J. A,Menton, C.. (2003). The relationship between incarcerated batterers’ cognitive characteristics and the effectiveness of behavioral treatment. Corrections Compendium. 28. 1-27
  • Jones, A. S,Gondolf, E. W.. (2002). Assessing the effect of batterer program completion on reassault: An instrumental variables analysis. Journal of Quantitative Criminology. 18. 71-98
  • Labriola, M,Rempel, M,Davis, R. C.. (2005). Testing the effectiveness of batterer programs and judicial monitoring. Results from a randomized trial at the Bronx Misdemeanor Domestic Violence Court. Center for Court Innovation. Nueva York, NY.
  • Levesque, D. A,Gelles, R. J.. (1998). Does treatment reduce recidivism in men who batter? A meta-analytic evaluation of treatment outcome. Paper presented at the Program Evaluation and Family Violence Research: An International Conference. Durham, NH.
  • (1979). Ley Orgánica 1/1979, de 26 de septiembre, General Penitenciaria. Boletín Oficial del Estado. 281. 33987
  • Lila, M,Gracia, E,Catalá-Miñana, A.. (2018). Individualized motivational plans in batterer intervention programs: A randomized clinical trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 86. 309
  • Lila, M,Martín-Fernández, M,Gracia, E,López-Ossorio, J. J,González, J. L.. (2019). Identifying key predictors of recidivism among offenders attending a batterer intervention program: A survival analysis. Psychosocial Intervention. 28. 157
  • Lin, S,Su, C,Chou, F. H,Chen, S,Huang, J,Wu, G. T,Chen, W. J,Chao, S. S,Chen, C.. (2009). Domestic violence recidivism in high-risk Taiwanese offenders after the completion of violence treatment programs. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology. 20. 458
  • Martín, A. M,Padrón, F,Redondo, S.. (2019). Early narratives of desistance from crime in different prison regimes. European Journal of Psychology Applied to Legal Context. 11. 71
  • Martín, B,Moral, M. V.. (2019). Relación entre dependencia emocional y maltrato psicológico en forma de victimización y agresión en jóvenes [Relationship between emotional dependence and psychological abuse in the form of victimization and aggression in young people]. Revista Iberoamericana de Psicología y Salud. 10. 75-89
  • Martín-Fernández, M,Gracia, E,Lila, M.. (2018). Assessing victim-blaming attitudes in cases of intimate partner violence against women: Development and validation of the VB-IPVAW scale. Psychosocial Intervention. 27. 133
  • Martín-Fernández, M,Gracia, E,Marco, M,Vargas, V,Santirso, F. A,Lila, M.. (2018). Measuring acceptability of intimate partner violence against women: Development and validation of the A-IPVAW scale. European Journal of Psychology Applied to Legal Context. 10. 26-34
  • Maruna, S.. (2004). Desistance and explanatory style: A new direction in the psychology of reform. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice. 20. 184-200
  • Monteiro, A,Vázquez, M. J,Seijo, D,Arce, R.. (2018). ¿Son los criterios de realidad válidos para clasificar y discernir entre memorias de hechos auto-experimentados y de eventos vistos en vídeo? [Are the reality criteria valid to classify and to discriminate between memories of self-experienced events and memories of video-observed events?]. Revista Iberoamericana de Psicología y Salud. 9. 149
  • Mosier, C. I.. (1943). On the reliability of a weighted composite. Psychometrika. 8. 161
  • Murphy, C. M,Musser, P. H,Maton, K. I.. (1998). Coordinated community intervention for domestic abusers: Intervention system involvement and criminal recidivism. Journal of Family Violence. 13. 263
  • Novo, M,Fariña, F,Seijo, D,Arce, R.. (2012). Assessment of a community rehabilitation programme in convicted male intimate-partner violent offenders. International Journal of Clinical and Health Psychology. 12. 219
  • Pérez, M.,Giménez-Salinas, A.,Juan, M.. (2012). Evaluación del programa “Violencia de género: programa de intervención para agresores”, en medidas alternativas. Instituto de Ciencias Forenses y de la Seguridad y Secretaría General de Instituciones Penitenciarias. Madrid, Spain.
  • Podsakoff, P. M,MacKenzie, S. B,Lee, J.-Y,Podsakoff, N. P.. (2003). Common method bias in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies. Journal of Applied Psychology. 88. 879-903
  • Redondo, S,Sánchez-Meca, J,Garrido, V.. (2001). Treatment of offenders and recidivism: Assessment of the effectiveness of programmes applied in Europe. Psychology in Spain. 5. 47-62
  • Redondo, S,Sánchez-Meca, J,Garrido, V.. (2002). Los programas psicológicos con delincuentes y su efectividad: la situación europea [Psychological programmes with offenders and their effectiveness: The European situation]. Psicothema. 14. 164
  • Rosenfeld, B. D.. (1992). Court ordered treatment of spouse abuse. Clinical Psychology Review. 12. 205
  • Rosnow, R. L,Rosenthal, R.. (1988). Focused tests of significance and effect size estimation in counseling psychology. Journal of Counseling Psychology. 35. 203
  • Saunders, D. G.. (1996). Feminist-cognitive-behavioral and process-psychodynamic treatments for men who batter: Interaction of abuser traits and treatment models. Violence and Victims. 11. 393-414
  • Schmidt, F. L,Hunter, J. E.. (1981). Employment testing: Old theories and new research findings. American Psychologist. 36. 1128
  • Schmidt, F. L,Hunter, J. E.. (2015). Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting errors and bias in research findings. Sage.
  • Schmucker, M,Lösel, F.. (2015). The effects of sexual offender treatment on recidivism: An international meta-analysis of sound quality evaluations. Journal of Experimental Criminology. 11. 597-630
  • Stewart, L. A,Gabora, N,Kropp, P. R,Lee, Z.. (2014). Effectiveness of risk-needs-responsivity-based family violence programs with male offenders. Journal of Family Violence. 29. 151
  • Stith, S. M,Rosen, K. H,McCollum, E. E.. (2004). Treating intimate partner violence within intact couple relationships: Outcomes of multi-couple versus individual couple therapy. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. 30. 305
  • Stover, C. S.. (2005). Domestic violence research what have we learned and where do we go from here?. Journal of Interpersonal Violence. 20. 448
  • Taft, C. T,Murphy, C. M,Elliott, J. D,Morrel, T. M.. (2001). Attendance-enhancing procedures in group counseling for domestic abusers. Journal of Counseling Psychology. 48. 51-60
  • Taylor, B. G,Maxwell, C. D.. (2009). The effects of a short-term batterer treatment program for detained arrestees: A randomized experiment in the Sacramento County, California jail. Department of Justice, Crime and Violence Prevention Center. Sacramento, CA.
  • Tollefson, D. R,Gross, E.. (2006). Predicting recidivism following participation in a batterer treatment program. Journal of Social Service Research. 32. 39-62
  • Tollefson, D. R,Webb, K,Shumway, D,Block, S. H,Nakamura, Y.. (2009). A mind-body approach to domestic violence perpetrator treatment: Program overview and preliminary outcomes. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma. 18. 17-45
  • Tukey, J. W.. (1960). Contributions to probability and statistics. Stanford University Press.
  • Vilariño, M,Amado, B. G,Vázquez, M. J,Arce, R.. (2018). Psychological harm in women victims of intimate partner violence: Epidemiology and quantification of injury in mental health markers. Psychosocial Intervention. 27. 145
  • Vilariño, M,Fariña, F,Arce, R.. (2009). Discriminating real victims from feigners of psychological injury in gender violence: Validating a protocol for forensic settings. European Journal of Psychology Applied to Legal Context. 1. 221
Fonte de datos: Dialnet